Tyrone: Towering Height – Cousins Describe Living With Giant’s Gene

6 Apr

Márta Korbonits, Brendan Holland and the skeleton of Charles Byrne 
Márta Korbonits, Brendan Holland in front of the skeleton of Charles Byrne preserved in the Hunterian Museum, London. Photograph: Linda Nylind for the Guardian

In April 1782, a real, live giant appeared in London. Charles Byrne was said to be a majestic 8ft 4in (2.54 metres) in height and able to light his pipe on street lamps. Now, the macabre events that took place after his death have finally allowed modern genetics to deliver a new twist to the story of the “Irish Giant” – and could change the lives of patients today.

From double-headed cows to eight-legged pigs, the Georgians paid handsomely to gawp at all manner of wondrous creatures, and also people afflicted by rare conditions: bearded women, dwarves and giants. After death, many found their way to John Hunter, the anatomist and founder of modern surgery, who was an obsessive collector of anatomical curiosities. It is almost certain that he met Byrne – perhaps one of the tallest men ever to have lived – and decided that he had to have his skeleton.

But Byrne had other ideas. He not only refused Hunter’s requests for his body but asked to be buried at sea to make it an impossibility. Hunter was undeterred and, as Byrne’s health deteriorated, had the young man followed. In 1783, aged just 22, Byrne died and, according to his wishes, his coffin was taken to the coast by friends. Hunter’s agents then sprung into action, getting the friends drunk before switching the body for stones. Hunter then boiled the corpse for 24 hours to procure the bones and hid the skeleton, not daring to show it for many years.

Today, we would recognise Byrne’s gigantism as being caused by a tumour in the pituitary, the endocrine gland that secretes many essential hormones, including ones for growth. Depending on the patient’s age at the onset of the tumour, either gigantism or acromegaly (typically characterised by excessive growth of the jaw, hands and feet) develops but there are other problems, such as delayed puberty.

Márta Korbonits, a professor of endocrinology and metabolism at Barts and the London NHS Trust, has a special interest in an inherited form of pituitary tumour called familial isolated pituitary adenoma (Fipa), in particular a type caused by a variant in the AIP gene. She had already come across a family with several affected members in their recent history who hailed from County Tyrone, the same part of Ireland as Byrne. She began to wonder if they were linked – but to find out she needed some of his DNA.

In 2008, with the assistance of the Hunterian Museum at the Royal College of Surgeons in London, where Byrne’s skeleton is displayed, she was able to send two of his teeth off to a German lab more used to extracting DNA from recovered sabre-toothed tigers. Korbonits wasn’t initially very hopeful of an answer: “The lab had never had a sample that had been cooked for 24 hours,” she explains.

While she waited for the results, a man with a particular curiosity about Byrne, 58-year-old Irish businessman Brendan Holland, had got involved with TV documentary-maker Ronan McCloskey. Brendan, like other members of his family, had been affected by a pituitary tumour as a teenager. It was removed but left its mark. Holland is 2.06m (6ft 9in) tall, though still a foot shorter than Byrne, whose real height was 2.34m (7ft 8in). Both Holland and McCloskey came from Tyrone and were fascinated by the number of actual giants in the area, and by the way they figured in Irish folklore not as freaks, but as kings, seers and poets.

Holland was tested and found to have the AIP mutation. Then Korbonits’s results came back – Byrne carried the same mutation. “I always wondered, ‘Why me?'” says Brendan. “I’ve wanted to know all my life. And the connection with Byrne was a bonus.”

But was Byrne the first of his kind? Modelling work by Korbonits’s team, just published in the New England Journal of Medicine, showed that both Byrne and today’s patients inherited their genetic variant from the same common ancestor and that this mutation is some 1,500 years old. There really were giants in Ireland in far-off times.

The scientists’ calculations show that some 200 to 300 living people might be carrying this same mutation today, and their work makes it possible to trace carriers of this gene and treat patients before they grow to be a giant.

Holland feels nothing but sympathy for Byrne. “He was a man born at the wrong time,” he says. “He knew he wasn’t well and he was genuinely an object of fascination at a time when the average man was only 5ft 5in. I’ve learned to live with it; Byrne never could.” As for Hunter, in his haste to boil the body he never looked inside Byrne’s skull, where the indentation of a pituitary tumour is plain to see. Had he done so, the cause of gigantism would have been another of his medical firsts.

Charles Byrne – The Irish Giant, featuring Brendan Holland, airs on BBC2 Northern Ireland on 16 January. For more information on AIP mutations visit fipapatients.org.


TWO Irish cousins with a giant gene which triggers uncontrolled body growth have opened up about living with the condition which caused their towering height.

Brendan Holland, who is six foot eight, from Tyrone and his six foot four inch cousin Niamh Feeney from Sligo are both termed pituitary giants by the medical profession.

In a new TG4 documentary, the pair discover they are the living relatives of a 18th century Tyrone man, Charles Byrne, who stood almost eight feet tall.

DNA taken from the 250- year-old skeleton of Byrne has led to the recent discovery of a gigantism gene by scientists.

It is believed the mutant gene, which first emerged 1,500 years ago, gave rise to a race of Irish giants in the north of the country.

Tyrone businessman Brendan Holland, 58, said he was relieved to discover genetics was responsible for the condition which he shared with his ancestor.

He said: “When I first heard the phrase pituitary gigantism I remember being uncomfortable with the description of it but it is, of course, an accurate description.

“It had a certain effect on me. Am I a giant? There is no doubt the normal human reaction of people is they stand sort of open-mouthed. It’s almost as if the journey has come full circle. I could quite happily die now because it has always intrigued me as to why me?”

The documentary, Charles Byrne — An Fathach Éireannach, reveals how the mutant gene makes carriers more likely to develop a condition which triggers too much growth hormone during childhood.

In the programme, Sligo woman Niamh Feeney said she has found it difficult to cope with her height.

She said: “Even now people would give me a second look in town. I just hate it. I absolutely hate it. I know they don’t mean to do it. Even small children when I’m queuing for something come up to me and look up.”

Professor Marta Korbonits, who a specialist in the condition, said pituitary gigantism arises due to a benign tumour of the pituitary gland which gives rise to too much growth hormone.

“If the patient becomes a giant it is because this tumour started in childhood while the bones are still able to grow in length.

“This is quite a serious disease. It has symptoms which could affect the quality and length of life. Patients with untreated gigantism usually die early.”

Doctors weren’t sure at first if the DNA from Charles Byrne was usable after 250 years but it proved to be intact and a firm link was found to Mr Holland.

“The chance that Brendan and Charles Byrne have the same common ancestor is very high and it’s practically impossible they are not related to each other,” said Professor Korbonits.

* Charles Byrne — An Fathach Éireannach will be broadcast on TG4 tonight at 9.30pm, and repeated on Saturday at 8.10pm.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: